 |
City Manager |
Corporate and Protective Services |
Community Services |
Economic Development |
Financial Services |
Engineering
|
Appendix F: Findings With Respect to
Transportation |
F. Findings with Respect to Transportation
Transportation is a critical link in achieving full
participation in community life including employment, recreation, shopping, and
medical/social services. Residents of rural communities face a number of
challenges with respect to available and affordable transportation to services
and employment opportunities. Urban communities with populations under 25,000
people find it difficult to bridge the gap between cost-effective public
transportation and the needs of community members.
Community transportation is described by the Wainwright
District Council as involving four sectors:
-
Public Transportation: provided by municipalities for
the general public and for people with specialized transportation needs
-
School Transportation: provided by private school bus
operators through contracts with school boards
-
Health Transportation: provided through public or
private ambulance operators, hospitals, and long-term care agencies
-
Social Transportation: provided or purchased by or
through agencies serving people with developmental disabilities, day care
centres, vocational rehabilitation services, and other social service
agencies.
The findings in this section of the report reflect the
secondary data collection together with the commonalities identified through the
primary data collection process with respect to:
community consultation
characteristics
gaps and concerns
potential solutions.
Observations:
the most common concerns voiced by respondents
were the lack of regional transportation, lack of transportation for those
who require treatment outside the community, and affordability in general
the community offers good accessibility to major
highways, and both local and international airports
options are available locally for short distance
transportation within Camrose County, and long distance outside the community
a number of options are available within the City of
Camrose including several taxi companies
cost can be a barrier to individuals operating on a
low-income budget, to students with young children, and to patients requiring
treatment in another community
opportunities appear to exist to co-ordinate
existing transportation services and programs more effectively, and for social
service agencies to work more closely together to develop solutions for
clients who require treatment outside the community
F.1 Community Consultation
Table F1: Community Consultation
|
Strengths |
Concerns/Gaps/Barriers |
Opportunities |
|
accessibility to major highways
accessibility to local and international airports
existing programs and services related to
transportation
taxi rates are reasonable
transportation program for cancer patients
willingness of neighbours and volunteers to provide
transportation
when necessary the City is small enough to walk across
town
|
cost for students who are single mothers to
drop off and pick up child from daycare on the way to/from school
cost of transportation for low-income individuals
living in east end who work in the west end
cost of transportation for patients requiring
treatment in another community
cost of transportation for seniors who are travelling
to more than one destination in the community
availability of transportation to young families and
seniors who live in the rural areas
little or no support for new and/or transient families
in rural areas
lack of a regional transportation service
|
co-ordination of existing services and
programs to utilize existing vehicles more effectively
work more closely with funding agencies to provide
more cost effective transportation for patients requiring treatment out
of the community
encourage a private sector operator to develop a
public transportation system
transportation vouchers provided for those in need
encourage local taxi services to reduce the fares for
those in need
lobby government for assistance in developing a public
transportation system
|
F.2 Characteristics
The following will provide an overview of:
|
local transportation
rail transportation
|
ground transportation
air transportation
|
Observations:
the Camrose area is well connected via
air, rail and ground transportation
although there is not a public transit
system in the community, a range of private and not-for-profit organizations
provide local service
taxi service can become costly for
residents, particularly if they are making a stop on the way to or from their
destination
although the Canadian Cancer Society
provides inexpensive volunteer service to assist patients in reaching their
appointments in Edmonton and there is a “Care Cars” program in place, it is
costly for dialysis patients travelling to Wetaskiwin for treatment
F.2.1 Local Transportation
local taxi companies include Camrose Courtesy
Cabs, Greyline Taxi, Lakeside Taxi and Armand’s Cabs
the Rose City Handivan Society in Camrose provides
transportation within the city and area for seniors and disabled clients and
all the school bus service for disabled children
the Bashaw Bus Society provides transportation for
all ages within the town and from Bashaw to Camrose with a stop in New Norway
on specific days
Greyhound Bus Lines offers inter-community passenger
and freight service three times daily with stops in Camrose and Bashaw
Battle River School Division operates rural school
buses for both public and Catholic. Allan Hay provides school bus
transportation within the city of Camrose
Cornerstone Christian Academy provides bussing for
their students also with the cost being part of the monthly school fees
Companions for Senior Citizens and Integrated
Lifestyles both provide transportation with companions to seniors and disabled
individuals 24/7 for a fee
Providence Place in Daysland has a handivan they
rent from the Daysland & District Aging In Place Foundation which is
available to take Bawlf & Rosalind residents of all ages to Daysland or
Camrose for appointments as needed for a small fee. The handivan can be
chartered as well for groups. To date it has not been taken advantage of by
the Camrose county residents.
Neighbourlink provides volunteer drivers from local
churches for people in need to get to appointments within the county
and surrounding area
Plan it Consulting/We Care Service has a handivan
available only with Companions which will take seniors and disabled anywhere
within Alberta 24/7 for a fee
Canadian Cancer Society uses volunteers to provide
transportation to cancer patients to major centres for treatment
Camrose has 7 courier/delivery services based in
town that service both the city and county and is also serviced by the major
national delivery services
more than a dozen trucking firms provide services to
the area and terminal facilities are available.
F.2.2 Ground Transportation
Highway 2 - a direct link to Edmonton and Calgary
about half an hour from the community
Highway 13 - east from the Saskatchewan
border west to Highway 2 providing access to Edmonton and other points across
Alberta
Highway 21 - north to Edmonton providing access to
Miquelon Provincial Park and south to Highway 1 (TransCanada Highway) direct
link to Calgary
Highway 26 - east from Camrose to the Ribstone
Historical sites
Highway 53 - east/west through the county to Highway
2 via Ponoka
Highway 56 - north/south on an alternate route to
the TransCanada Highway through Drumheller providing access to the Badlands
tourism area and the Big Valley Jamboree.
Table F2: Proximity to Major Centres by Road
|
City |
Approximate Driving Distances (km) |
|
Vancouver |
1193 |
|
Edmonton |
97 |
|
Calgary |
274 |
|
Red Deer |
129 |
|
Saskatoon |
469 |
|
Toronto |
3366 |
|
Montreal |
3653 |
|
Grand Forks |
1434 |
|
Minneapolis |
1914 |
|
Denver |
2207 |
|
Chicago |
2584 |
F.2.3 Rail Transportation
Both Canadian National and Canadian Pacific Railways provide
freight service to the area. Canadian National provides rail service to the Town
of Bashaw. Spur lines are available in two industrial parks.
F.2.4 Air Transportation
Calgary International Airport is about 280 kilometres from
the community and Edmonton International Airport is about 72 kilometers from the
Camrose area. Both provide passenger and cargo service together with a number of
consumer services including gift shops, foreign exchange, book shops, hotel,
restaurants and lounges, fast food centre, duty free shop, Customs clearance,
and ground transportation service. The Camrose Airport, in close proximity to
the community and 45 minutes from Edmonton International Airport, has a paved
and lighted 1,372m airstrip, terminal building, hangars and tie-downs.
Scheduled airline service from both International Airports to
destinations all over the world is provided by a broad range of airline agencies
and operators including Air Canada, Air Transat, Canadian North Airlines,
WestJet, Horizon Air, Northwest Airlines, LOT Polish Airlines, Martinair, Tango
Air.
Table F3: Proximity to Major Centres by Air
(Leaving from Edmonton International Airport)
|
City |
Approximate Hours of Air Travel (direct where possible) |
|
Vancouver |
1 hour 35 minutes |
|
Winnipeg |
1 hour 51 minutes |
|
Saskatoon |
1 hour 20 minutes |
|
Toronto |
3 hours 40 minutes |
|
Montreal |
5 hours 9 minutes |
|
Chicago |
6 hours 57 minutes |
|
Denver |
4 hours 43 minutes |
|
Minneapolis |
7 hours 17 minutes |
F.3 Gaps and Concerns
Table F4 sets out the findings identified through
consultation with the community, observations with respect to the community, and
a review of the existing programs and services.
Table F4: Gaps, Concerns and Contributing Factors
|
Gap/Concern/ Unmet Need |
Contributing Factors |
|
Regional transportation |
trends such as lower income families moving to
more rural areas
population aging and decrease in “driving” seniors
|
|
Transportation for those who require treatment outside the community |
aging population
growth in technology and newer
treatment opportunities requiring specialized treatments not available in
the community
|
|
Affordability |
students and lower-income families need to ferry
children to childcare providers, stop for groceries, etc.
|
F.4 Potential Solutions
A rural transportation is vital to the community. The service
may be a scheduled fixed-route service, dial-a-ride, ridesharing, vanpooling,
friendly trips, or some other mode. A “Rural Transit Service Design and
Scheduling” framework developed by the Community Transportation Association
will be included with the literature reviewed during this process.
To be effective and lasting, these local solutions must be
operated by the individual community to meet local needs. The participation of
volunteers is essential to keep costs affordable, and users are asked to pay a
fee.
The Holden Transportation Project (Beaver Call
A Ride Service) initiated in 1997 by the Beaver County Action Committee
coordinates the Town of Holden system (seniors only) and the rural system to
serve low-income families and the disabled. Clients must be fully mobile or
accompanied by a friend or family member. Utilizing private vehicles and trained
volunteer drives to provide transportation service to clients, the system also
provides shuttle services to Edmonton, Viking, Camrose and Tofield. A one-time
grant from Health Canada currently assists with the coordinator’s salary
however the Society will need to fundraise in the future. the service is
subsidized 50% by the Society and 50% by client with some exceptions as
necessary. Training includes professional driver training programs ($100), first
aid training, mechanical inspection of vehicles and increased insurance
premiums. Drivers receive a remuneration of .035 cents/km for vehicle expenses.
The Wainwright Transportation Initiative
provides a coordinated transportation service for the Town of Wainwright and the
MD utilizing the 5 existing vans/buses. The pooling of resources from public,
health, social and school sectors is intended to provide a coordinated and
consolidated transportation system.
A Seniors Services Program of Champaign County
in Illinois developed a rural transportation program providing free door-to-door
service for residents of rural Champaign County. Van routes travel within the
County on four scheduled routes. Reservations are required and medical
appointments receive the highest priority service. This service is provided in
partnership with the American Red Cross.
Another Family and Senior Transportation Service
in rural Illinois is offered through the Family Services agency. It provides
transportation for individuals 60 years of age and over to and from doctor,
dental, business appointments or the grocery store. Every effort is made to
obtain a ride with a volunteer for each senior. When a volunteer cannot be
found, a cab service may be used. Cab rides are provided at half the normal
fare. Grocery van rides are available with set routes and operating weekly from
different parts of the County. Seniors may ride on the grocery van once a week
and requests must be called into the centre in advance. This is a partnership
between state and municipal governments, community-based human service agencies,
cab companies and resident volunteers.
The Community Transportation Assistance Program in
Nova Scotia promotes the delivery of, and provides operating support for,
cost effective and sustainable community-based transportations services in rural
and low population density population areas in Nova Scotia. Funding for the
program, in the form of grants, is available to municipalities and
not-for-profit community-based organizations.
The Manitoba government assisted rural communities in
setting up and operating handivan services through its Program for
Transportation of the Mobility Disadvantaged. In other communities school
buses are used off hours or car pools are created with volunteer drivers.
In Saskatchewan the Rural Transportation Assistance
Program was established to provide connection from isolated areas to towns
on a commercial bus line.
|