 |
City Manager |
Corporate and Protective Services |
Community Services |
Economic Development |
Financial Services |
Engineering
|
Appendix A: Approach and Process |
A. APPROACH AND PROCESS
A.1 GOALS, OBJECTIVES AND ANTICIPATED OUTPUTS
A.1.1 Goal
SMT Business Services Inc. understood the purpose of this
project to be:
to undertake a Community Social Needs Assessment
and Employment/Training Needs Assessment, and to provide recommendations to
address identified issues.
A.1.2 Objectives
SMT Business Services Inc. understood the four main
objectives of this project to be as follows:
to define and assess specific needs related to the overall health
of the City of Camrose
to identify current, emerging and future needs and trends
to increase awareness of existing challenges, and associated programs
and services
to develop a strategic planning framework that lays the groundwork
for actions that will address the identified issues
A.1.3 Anticipated Results/Outputs
The following sets out the results and outputs that SMT
Business Services Inc. anticipated from this project:
a comprehensive report setting out the activities
and process involved with the project and the resulting findings and
recommendations
an environmental scan of the community
a statistical poverty profile
an inventory of the existing Social Services Network
a baseline assessment of the social needs of the
residents of the City of Camrose including housing, transportation, child care
needs, youth needs, senior needs, disabled needs, and family needs
a description of how these needs are currently being
met
an inventory of unmet needs which identifies the
nature and extent of the gaps between existing programs and the needs/desires
of the residents
a scan of similar communities in other jurisdictions
to identify potential models for addressing gaps
a summary of current and future trends and patterns
that may impact on the community and the specific stakeholder groups
a summary of any issues emerging from the process
that were not part of the original mandate
recommendations with respect to the data collected,
gaps, emerging issues, current and future trends and patterns, and action
steps
enhanced understanding of needs and challenges of
the stakeholders
two (2) presentations of the report to stakeholder
groups as desired by the Steering Committee.
A.2 SMT’s Approach
Projects undertaken by SMT Business Services Inc. have
involved a cooperative working relationship with the Steering Committee and the
Project Coordinator. SMT’s approach is usually a practical one in which the
Steering Committee contributes expertise with respect to the Community and its
background, while SMT brings the expertise, and the consultation, research and
planning skills to bear on the project.
SMT’s approach to developing comprehensive and effective
recommendations encourages “buy-in” from internal and external stakeholders,
decision-makers, and community members; and promotes the enthusiasm,
understanding and commitment needed to implement the resulting recommendations.
This approach usually includes supporting the Steering Committee or
Implementation Team in its presentation of the findings at the community level,
as identified in the deliverables/outputs component of the project-specific
proposal.
Following are the five phases of the proposed methodology
used by SMT Business Services
Inc.:
· Phase
I:
Design of the Framework
· Phase
II:
Primary and Secondary Data Collection and Analysis
· Phase
III:
Development of Findings and Recommendations
· Phase
IV:
Presentation of Preliminary Report
· Phase
V:
Submission of the Final Report.
A.3 The Steering Committee
The Steering Committee was coordinated by Gary Gibeault and
included:
Denis Beesley, The Bethany Group
Mary Durand, Councillor City of Camrose
Ken Flater, Community at Large
Gary Gibeault, City Manager City of Camrose
Wendy Gregg, Camrose & District FCSS
Garth Horton, Alberta Human Resources and
Employment
John Howard, Gardner College
Ina Nielsen, Councillor City of Camrose.
A.4 Data Collection
In keeping with the process set out in the draft framework,
and agreed to by the Steering Committee, data were collected in a variety of
ways including key stakeholder interviews, random telephone interviews, group
discussions, and questionnaires. As the data was collected it was validated to
ensure an accurate reflection of the community’s needs and issues. Emerging
issues that may not have been anticipated have been identified for review by the
Steering Committee.
A.4.1 Literature Review
A review of a variety of documents and reports was conducted.
This review provided an overview of the trends and patterns in the area and the
resulting issues. The listing below sets out the types of information and
sources accessed:
Annual reports of various community-based and
regional support services
Recommendations from the Beyond Economic Growth:
Building Health Communities Conference
Alberta 2002 Future Summit
AUMA Housing Policies Report
What Is Health Report by Headwaters Health Authority
CMHC Sustainable Planning Workshop, and models, best
practices
Rocky Mountain House homeless initiative
Cochrane Housing Initiative
New Brunswick Housing Initiative
Westarc Seniors Helping Seniors Initiative
No Safeguards: A Profile of Urban Poverty in Alberta
CCSD: Statistical Profiles of Urban poverty in
Canada
National Council on Welfare: Poverty Profile 1998
and 1999
Grande Prairie Social Housing Project, and Youth
Initiative Reports
City of Edmonton Low Income and Special Needs
Housing Strategy
Social Planning: A Community Meeting -Camrose
October 1999
People Patterns Trends and Patterns 2000
Rural Youth: Stayers, Leavers and
City of Camrose Strategic Plan
City of Camrose reports on housing and
transportation
City of Camrose Census 2001
City of Camrose housing statistics
Alberta Recreation Survey 2000
What Works Alberta newsletters
Statistics Canada year 2000 taxfiler data for
Camrose
Statistics Canada reports, census data, studies
Prepared for Growth, Building Alberta’s Labour
Supply, October 2001
the Riley Guide: Preparing for a Job Search
The Road Ahead Labour Market Trends and Realities
Central Alberta Labour Market Review
AHR&E Labour Market Trends
AHR&E 2001 Annual Alberta Labour Market Review
AHR&E Labour Force Statistics April 2002-05-25
HRDC Emerging Sectors and Occupations
HRDC Occupational and Sectoral Profiles
Alberta Economic Development Sectoral Profiles
HRDC Key Economic Factors
HRDC Overview of Outlooks by Occupation
HRDC Overview of Labour Market Trends
Statistics Canada - Perspectives
Statistics Canada Recent Releases
Countdown to Future Shortages in the Canadian Labour
Market
Return Migrants 2000
Youth in Transition Survey 2002
Statistics Canada - Infomat
Municipal data and information
Municipal business directories
Home Based Business Outlook
Small Business Statistics
The Future Workforce and the Future Worker
Decline in Youth Participation Rate Since 1990
Canadian Federation of Independent Business Needs
Assessment Surveys 2001
Portrait of Small Business 2000
Canadian Business Labour Market Survey
Small Business Needs Assessment - Industry Canada
2001
Future Knowledge 2001
USA Employment Forecast
Monthly Economic Reviews
City of Edmonton 2001 Workforce Connector
summaries of industry-specific studies developed by
sectoral councils and industry organizations
profiles, etc. of all partners, supporters, enablers
myriad of websites, web pages and research data
A.4.2 Surveys, Interviews, Focus Groups
Table A1 sets out the consultation activities and the results
of the process.
Table A1: Results of Community Consultation Process
|
Activity |
Targeted Participants |
Actual Results |
Response Rate |
|
Surveys: Community Survey
Student Survey
Business Survey |
5,000
750
858 |
487
355
281 |
9%
47%
32% |
|
Interviewees:
Business
Service Providers, Key Stakeholders Residents
External agencies, organizations, etc. |
120
200
300
50 |
120
247
300
53 |
n/a |
|
Discussion Groups:
Students, Business, Service Providers
Users, Community Meetings Attended |
n/a |
7 groups and 6 community meetings attended |
n/a |
A.5 Recognition of Barriers and Issues
In the course of completing any project successfully,
barriers and issues arise. Those occurring in this project include the
following:
detailed year 2000 Statistics Canada data not
currently available
statistical information with respect to actual
current numbers and historical data not always readily available from service
providers.
A.6 Presentation of Findings in Strategic Planning Workshop
A comprehensive draft report documenting the activities and
setting out the findings and associated recommendations was presented to the
Steering Committee. It is the usual practice of SMT Business Services Inc. to
present the draft report in a workshop format with the anticipated purpose of:
reviewing the key findings and recommendations
contained in the report
providing the Steering Committee with an opportunity
to discuss same as a group
summarizing the ideas/feedback resulting from the
discussion and identifying priority issues
advancing notional plans for dissemination and
presentation of the information.
The Steering Committee chose a different path, preferring to
review the document individually and as a group and to submit their feedback to
SMT Business Services Inc. via email. Recognizing that there may be some value
in discussing questions re: the report, a representative of the Steering
Committee did have conversations with the consulting group to clarify questions
and perceptions.
SMT Business Services Inc. usually assists in the development
of the material that the Steering Committee will present, acting as a resource
during such presentation. Although SMT did provide an electronic copy of the
August 27th presentation, the Steering Committee seemed inclined to develop
their own material, and to present the findings and recommendations to Council
on their own.
SMT Business Services Inc. reviewed the feedback from the
Steering Committee re: the draft report with Steering Committee Member Wendy
Gregg, and consensus on the amendments to be made was reached.
Upon completion of the review of the draft report, the
Steering Committee requested that SMT Business Services Inc. assist in the
development of the two key presentations.
The physical deliverables including 25 bound copies of the
final report package, one unbound copy of the final report package, and an
electronic copy of the final report package as per the proposal were delivered
to the City of Camrose within 5 days of receiving the Steering Committee’s
feedback.
|